Reply
Occasional Collector
Codex
Posts: 2
Registered: ‎12-04-2010
0
Accepted Solution

Sophos Mac Home Ed.'s MD5 checksum wrong?

I performed a md5 check on the file I downloaded from Sophos' website (savosx_72_he.dmg), but I received a different string from the one listed on the tech specs page.

 

I got this result: 76cbd8b25919c3fda4690f36219a1f8b

Sophos shows: 21c3c6f2d93d0843238b9575792e06ef

 

Someone please explain the discrepancy? I've downloaded the file twice

 

Thanks.

Moderator
sandy
Posts: 138
Registered: ‎09-20-2010
0

Re: Sophos Mac Home Ed.'s MD5 checksum wrong?

Hi Codex and welcome to the forum.

 

The checksum currently (Monday 13.55) on the downloads site check page is the same as the one you saw in the file you downloaded. So that is correct.

Where did you obtain the checksum that you mention below as 'Sophos shows', starting with 21c ?

 

Thanks

Sandy


Sandy.
Communities Moderator.

If a response provided a solution, please mark your question as solved. If others are helpful, show your appreciation by giving them Kudos.
Occasional Collector
Codex
Posts: 2
Registered: ‎12-04-2010
0

Re: Sophos Mac Home Ed.'s MD5 checksum wrong?

Sandy, Thanks for your help. I found the checksum on the following site: http://www.sophos.com/products/free-tools/free-mac-anti-virus/tech-specs.html Surprisingly, it still shows "21c3c6f2d93d0843238b9575792e06ef" as the correct checksum. Regards, Codex
VIP
QC
Posts: 233
Registered: ‎11-02-2010

Re: Sophos Mac Home Ed.'s MD5 checksum wrong?

The FAQ refers you to the Tech specs page (Make a note of this checksum and compare it with the checksum provided on the tech specs page) which indeed lists the "old" MD5  whereas How to check that your download is genuine – using a checksum from the Mac tools help indicates the Sophos downloads webpage as the authoritative source (Make a note of this checksum and compare it with the checksum provided in the file on the Sophos downloads webpage).

 

To avoid (future) confusion either the two should be kept in sync or the Tech specs should refer to the file in the on the downloads page. BTW (it has already been mentioned): Neither might satisfy the truly paranoid as both fail over a https connection.

 

Christian

Moderator
sandy
Posts: 138
Registered: ‎09-20-2010
0

Re: Sophos Mac Home Ed.'s MD5 checksum wrong?

I have addressed the issue over the discrepancy with the checksum, it will be rectified shortly.

 

I am unable to finds any reference to issues with viewing checksum over https (if that is what you mean).

 

If someone can point me in the right direction I will investigate.

 

Thanks a lot

Sandy.


Sandy.
Communities Moderator.

If a response provided a solution, please mark your question as solved. If others are helpful, show your appreciation by giving them Kudos.
VIP
QC
Posts: 233
Registered: ‎11-02-2010
0

Re: Sophos Mac Home Ed.'s MD5 checksum wrong?

I am unable to finds any reference to issues with viewing checksum over https (if that is what you mean).

Only two posts (now three) are found for md5 https and the one not from me is from the thread Protection against MiTM attacks?. jstash says in his second post: An MD5 published on an HTTP site (which could also be hijacked) is only sufficient for checking if a download is intact. To verify that it was actually created by Sophos, either a signature file (e.g. validating a PGP/GPG signature file) or being able to download the MD5 over HTTPS (w/ cert validation)  [bold print mine] would be needed.

 

Christian